Home » Recipes » Amish Custard Pie Suggestions? Amish Custard Pie - Recipe Cost Cost information for the following is not included. Normally this is because the quantity or ingredient is unknown 1 x 9" unbaked pie shell Ingredients Per Recipe Qty Common Price Price per Recipe 1/3 c. Sugar 1/3 cup $1.44 per pound $0.21 2 tsp Flour 2 tsp $2.99 per 5 pounds $0.01 1/2 tsp Salt 1/2 tsp $2.91 per 16 ounces $0.02 3 x Large eggs 3 eggs $2.53 per 12 items $0.63 3 c. Lowfat milk 3 cup $3.99 per gallon $0.75 1/4 tsp Nutmeg 1/4 tsp n/a Total Recipe $1.62 Please Log In or Sign Up to edit Recipe Cost info Email Recipe Cost Send To Message (if any) or Close